Appeal with the Board of Immigration appeals
Appeal with the Board of Immigration appeals
/
When an immigration case is denied or receives an unfavorable decision, individuals have the option to file an appeal with the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA). The BIA the highest administrative appellate body for interpreting and applying immigration laws. The BIA is responsible for adjudicating appeals originating from Immigration Judges or decisions made by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).
While the BIA headquarters is situated in Falls Church, Virginia, it operates as an integral component of the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), placing it within the federal court system and granting it nationwide jurisdiction.
The BIA exclusively entertains appeals arising from decisions made by Immigration Judges and, on rare occasions, officials from the DHS. The BIA does not, however, have jurisdiction over appeals originating from the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), the agency responsible for overseeing numerous immigration applications and petitions.
In the event that you intend to appeal a decision rendered by a USCIS official, it is advisable to direct your appeal, motion for reconsideration, or motion to reopen the case to the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO). The AAO is the appropriate authority for addressing challenges to USCIS decisions, ensuring a proper channel for reviewing and resolving immigration-related matters.
Individuals seeking representation in BIA appeals must engage the services of licensed attorneys or certified BIA representatives.
While the BIA headquarters is situated in Falls Church, Virginia, it operates as an integral component of the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), placing it within the federal court system and granting it nationwide jurisdiction.
The BIA exclusively entertains appeals arising from decisions made by Immigration Judges and, on rare occasions, officials from the DHS. The BIA does not, however, have jurisdiction over appeals originating from the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), the agency responsible for overseeing numerous immigration applications and petitions.
In the event that you intend to appeal a decision rendered by a USCIS official, it is advisable to direct your appeal, motion for reconsideration, or motion to reopen the case to the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO). The AAO is the appropriate authority for addressing challenges to USCIS decisions, ensuring a proper channel for reviewing and resolving immigration-related matters.
Individuals seeking representation in BIA appeals must engage the services of licensed attorneys or certified BIA representatives.
The decisions addressed by Immigration Judges and handled by the BIA encompass various aspects, such as:
- Asylum Cases: Delving into situations where individuals seek protection due to a credible fear of persecution based on factors like race, religion, nationality, political beliefs, or social affiliations.
- Removal Proceedings & Deportation Cases: Addressing legal processes related to the potential removal of individuals from the country.
- Exclusion Orders: Examining cases involving the exclusion of individuals from entry into the United States.
- Motions to Reopen: Handling appeals seeking a review of a case that has been closed, allowing for new evidence or legal arguments.
- Motions to Reconsider: Addressing appeals for a reconsideration of a decision previously made, providing an opportunity to present additional arguments or evidence.
- Bond Denial Cases: Addressing situations where individuals are denied bond during immigration proceedings.
During credible fear hearings, immigrants present their case before an immigration judge, articulating their experiences or fears of persecution based on factors such as race, religion, nationality, political beliefs, or social affiliations. If an immigration officer determines that credible fear is lacking, it may trigger the initiation of removal proceedings.
Cases falling under the purview of DHS decisions that the BIA can appeal encompass:
1
Certain DHS Penalties
Instances where the DHS imposes penalties warranting further review by the BIA.
2
Violations of Immigration Laws Resulting in DHS Fines
Situations involving fines levied by the DHS for breaches of immigration laws may be contested through the BIA.
3
Immigrant Relative Petitions
Appeals related to DHS decisions on petitions involving immigrant relatives, seeking to establish or reaffirm family ties.
4
Waivers of Inadmissibility
Cases dealing with waivers sought to overcome grounds of inadmissibility as determined by the DHS.
It is crucial to highlight that the DHS thoroughly reviews and adjudicates applications for adjustment of status. If, unfortunately, your application for adjustment of status is denied, seeking the assistance of an experienced immigration attorney becomes imperative. In such instances, the appeal process would involve the AAO rather than the BIA. To secure your rights and explore the best course of action, it is advised to promptly consult with an immigration attorney.
Requirements for Appeal with the Board of Immigration appeals
- Notice of Appeal: The first step in filing an appeal is to submit a Notice of Appeal with the BIA. The notice must be filed within the specified timeframe mentioned in the decision, typically within 30 days.
- Appealing A Removal Proceedings Decision: The BIA will need the EOIR-26 Form Notice of Appeal within 30 calendar days of the Immigration Judge’s decision.
- Adherence to Deadlines: It is crucial to adhere to the specified deadlines for filing the Notice of Appeal and submitting the supporting documents. Failure to meet these deadlines may result in the dismissal of the appeal.
- Brief or Written Statement: After filing the Notice of Appeal, the appellant (the person filing the appeal) must submit a brief or written statement explaining the legal arguments and reasons for appealing the decision. This document outlines the errors or issues in the previous decision and presents legal arguments to support the appeal.
- Record on Appeal: The appellant's attorney or representative requests the Record on Appeal, which includes all the documents, evidence, and transcripts from the previous immigration proceedings. This record is essential for the BIA's review of the case.
- Review by the BIA: The BIA reviews the written arguments, evidence, and the record on appeal. The board may also request additional information or clarification if necessary.
- Oral Argument: In some cases, the BIA may grant the appellant's request for an oral argument. This allows the appellant or their attorney to present their case in person before the board. However, oral arguments are not granted in all cases and are at the discretion of the BIA.
- Decision by the BIA: Once the review process is complete, the BIA issues a written decision on the appeal. The Board can affirm the previous decision, reverse it, or remand the case back to the immigration judge or USCIS officer for further consideration.
- Further Appeals: If the appellant disagrees with the BIA's decision, they may have further options for appeal, such as filing a petition for review with the appropriate U.S. Court of Appeals. You must file an appeal within 30 days of the BIA’s decision. It's important to note that the availability and process for further appeals may vary depending on the type of immigration case and the specific circumstances.
It is highly recommended to seek legal representation from an experienced immigration attorney when filing an appeal with the BIA. Immigration law can be complex, and an attorney can help navigate the process, prepare a strong legal argument, and ensure compliance with deadlines and requirements.
The success of an appeal often relies on the strength of the legal arguments presented. The appellant's brief or written statement should clearly identify the errors or issues in the previous decision and provide legal authority and evidence to support the requested relief.
The success of an appeal often relies on the strength of the legal arguments presented. The appellant's brief or written statement should clearly identify the errors or issues in the previous decision and provide legal authority and evidence to support the requested relief.
Filing an appeal with the Board of Immigration Appeals is a significant step in seeking a reversal or reconsideration of an unfavorable immigration decision. Our legal team is well-versed in these intricate matters, offering comprehensive support and guidance throughout the immigration appeals process. Trust us to advocate for your rights and provide strategic counsel tailored to your unique situation.